Go to PC Hardware main page
 
Advanced search here
Powered by www.pchardweb.com
Romaneste! You are not logged in. Register.  
23:21  
  All Cooler Reviews

Today news
Tagan TG480-U01 480W ATX / EPS Power Supply Review
Logitech MX 510 Performance Optical Mouse
8 Video Cards Roundup
Samsung SyncMaster 173P LCD Monitor Review
Aerocool HT-101 AMD/P4 HSF Review
Top Systems
Sisoft Sandra 2002 / Multimedia Float (it/s)
Sisoft Sandra 2002 / Multimedia Int (it/s)
Sisoft Sandra 2002 / Memory Float (Mb/s)
Sisoft Sandra 2002 / Memory Int (Mb/s)
Sisoft Sandra 2002 / CPU ALU (MIPS)
Advertisement
User Reviews
Shuttle AV61
MSI k7t pro 2-a
Abit KT7A
Abit KT7A
plz help with motherboard
Featured downloads
CPUInfo
Tweak Revisited
SoftFSB
Registry Styler 99
Icon 3D

 
 
  AMD and Intel Coolers roundup
Latest Coolers | Recommended Coolers
 
 Date July 24, 2001
 Author Selenty
 Manufacturer various
 Language English, Romanian

Since the explosive increase of electronic devices a very annoying problem occurred: how to cool down the silicon. I want to make from this article a practical one, that's why I don't want to enter into complicate physics. The electrons mobility is bigger in lower temperatures and this allows greater clock speeds and voltages applied to the silicone core. You know how important it is to keep the CPU cool these days; in the early times of computing it was unnecessary because the CPU didn't get much hotter than a low power transistor. With the clock increase the CPU needed more and more power to function so passive heatsinks became required. Later a fan was added to cool even more the heatsink surface. There are several external things which make computing unreliable, two of the most important being temperature and dust. The dust level is very hard to control, there are no simple devices able to keep the dust away. A sponge limits somehow the dust but it's not regarded as a serious solution in most media.

The good news is that we are able to control the temperature level, at least in a certain degree. Today I'll try to present you several traditional coolers which should be able to cool down your CPU no matter if it's a cheap Duron or a more expensive Pentium III. Let's go to work.
We defined several days ago the PC Hardware general testing methodology. Although we haven't defined a special section for coolers the testing procedure will be the same with a few amendments. As you may know we split the market in three segments: low price, medium price and high end. We have many coolers ready for testing today in all the three segments. From the beginning I was tempted to test the coolers in every market segment and to publish the results separately. The other option would have been to publish the results for every manufacturer that entered the roundup. In the end I decided to go for both. First I tested the coolers in every market category and in the end I make a comparison based on price and performance.
We have described almost all in the testing methodology but we haven't defined precise testing procedures so I will do it now. We have tested coolers that can work with both Intel and AMD CPUs but I preferred to run all the tests with AMD CPUs because these are more sensitive to temperature issues. I personally prefer real CPUs, no resistor simulators because these fail to simulate properly the small CPU core of the today CPUs.
In our testing procedure the case and the temperature in the case is not important because in Romania it's very hot these days (around 38-40C). The temperature in our building is around 23C which is positive because if would have been above 30C our tests hadn't had any relevance. Physics laws say that if two bodies exchange temperature the balance temperature is greater than the coldest and smaller than the warmer. With a medium temperature of about 23C we had the chance to measure the coolers efficiency.

Methodology

Below you can find the three market as defined by PC Hardware at this date:

  • Low market segment - coolers targeted to Athlon below 1.1Ghz. These coolers should be able to work with any Duron / Celeron and Pentium III below 1.13Ghz. Not suitable for overclocking, but you can push to the limits a 800Mhz Duron.
  • Medium market segment - coolers targeted to Athlon above 1.1Ghz and below 1.4Ghz. Any Duron / Celeron and Pentium III should work with these coolers. May be suitable for overclocking.
  • High end market segment - coolers targeted to Athlon beyond 1.4Ghz. These coolers are the best overclockers on the market and can work with any CPU that fits its design.
Motherboards Epox EP-8K7A+ for AMD CPUs
DFI CS62-TC for Intel CPUs
CPUs Low market segment: Thunderbird 750 Mhz @ 907Mhz (121FSB, 1.8V core)
Medium market segment: Thunderbird 1.1 Ghz @ 1331Mhz (121FSB, 1.85V core)
High end market: Thunderbird 1.4Ghz @ 1652 Mhz (118FSB, 1.85V core)
Coolers various
Memory Samsung 1 x 256Mb PC133 CAS2 / Corsair 128Mb PC133
Video Card Generic GeForce GTS 64Mb DDR
Hard disk Western Digital WD400BB 40Gb 7200rpm
Case open system
Software Windows 2000 SP2
SiSoft Sandra 2001 Professional
Id Software Quake III Arena
Motherboard Monitor 5.08

Every cooler was installed with the interface material provided. If the cooler didn't have an interface material build in we used thermal grease. The only cooler in this situation was the Thermalright SK6. Many people like to read the temperature with infrared rays or thermistor digital devices. We decided to use the software method although the temperature reading may not be the most correct one from two reasons. In order to precise test the temperature you have to drill a hole into the heatsink base and to introduce a probe as close to the CPU core as possible. It was not possible to do this because heatsinks are different and the method wouldn't have had relevance. The second reason is that using the software method the reading is impartial: all coolers are tested on the same platform and comparisons can be made. We stressed the system as much as were able to do with SiSoft Sandra 2001 Professional and Quake III and the maximum temperature on the CPU sensor was recorded.


 

Newsletter
Receive reviews, news,
performance increase tips

Subscribe Leave
Info and privacy here.
Contents
Inside the article:
Page 1 Methodology / Test system
Page 2 What we check
Page 3 Pentalpha APSK0138
Page 4 Coolermaster DP5-5G11B-01
Page 5 Pentalpha APSK0155
Page 6 Pentalpha APSK0166
Page 7 Millennium Electronics MCPU-2003
Page 8 Coolermaster EP5-6I11-A1
Page 9 Coolermaster EP5-6I51
Page 10 Millennium Electronics MCPU-1002A
Page 11 Millennium Electronics MCPU-1003A
Page 12 Tiger Electronics SDA38120BC
Page 13 Pentalpha APSK0160
Page 14 Thermalright SK6
Page 15 AKASA Silver Mountain
Page 16 Taisol CGK760092
Page 17 Taisol CGK74092
Page 18 Conclusions
Page 19 Final words
See also
Articles related to current:
Another cooler roundup
Socket A / socket 370 coolers round-up
AMD coolers round-up
2 Cool PC cooler
Thermal Interface Guide
Coolers modification
Advertisement

Discuss this article into the forum
Print this article
Mail a quote from this review to a friend
Rate this review! Rating: 8
Add your review about AMD and Intel Coolers roundup
Add your system to Performance Center
Next page:

About us | Contact us | Privacy policy | Forums | Members | Request a review

   @ 1998 - 2002 PC Hardware SRL. All rights reserved. Do you want to know more about Romania?