|
Test
system
Before going
to actual tests I have to tell you that you should not compare our
test results with the temperature showed by your motherboard monitor.
We invested a lot of time in making these results as accurate as
possible, but the main objective of this round up is the comparison.
The difference between our measurement method and the one displayed
by an Omega sensor installed on a Taisol using the AMD method was
at most 2.7degrees Celsius, so I think that the results are in an
acceptable accuracy interval.
This roundup
is targeted mainly to AMD CPUs, the reason why we tested the cooling
power with a 1.2Ghz Thunderbird overclocked to 1.33Ghz 1.85V core.
This CPU is loaded with more than 75W, so most coolers were stressed
by these conditions.
Due to users request this time we compared all the heatsinks, not
on the market target like in the previous article, but we suggested
the target market for every cooler. Take a look below to our test
bed:
| Motherboards |
MSI
K7T Limited Edition |
| CPUs |
Thunderbird 1.2Ghz @ 1333 Mhz (133FSB, 1.85V core) |
| Coolers |
various |
| Memory |
Corsair 128Mb PC133 |
| Video
Card |
Abit
Siluro MX400 |
| Hard
disk |
Western
Digital WD400BB 40Gb 7200rpm |
| Case |
open
system |
| Software |
MSI
PC Alert III
Passmark BurnIn Test 2.2 |
As you can see
we didn't use an out of ordinary system. Passmark BurnIn Test was
considered able to stress the system with no other help. In the
preliminary test sessions we ran several tests and we discovered
that BurnIn Test 2.2 is really a very powerful test for measuring
system stability. The ambient temperature was measured by an Omega
sensor placed at about 30cm distance away from the cooler not to
be influenced by the cooler airflow.
The noise was
measured at 30cm also. You will find that the fan specs talk about
a much lower noise than the results of our tests. There are multiple
reasons for this. Most manufacturers measure the noise 1m away from
the cooler, with no heatsink. When a heatsink is used the noise
level is bigger. In the specifications table you can find the noise
level rated by the manufacturer of the fan and in the test results
our results. |